I Keep Hiring People But It's Causing MORE Work: Why the Admin Hiring Model Is Broken

“I don't have time to train somebody. But I also can't keep doing everything myself.”
— Every roofing contractor trying to scale

If you’ve said this (or thought it), you’re not alone. For many roofing business owners, admin hiring feels like a treadmill: non-stop stretching, no finish line in sight.

Here’s why the traditional “hire more admin” model is broken, and what actually works instead.

The Hiring Treadmill

Here’s a pattern we see in roofing ops again and again:

  1. You hire an admin.
  2. You spend 2–3 months training them on systems like JobNimbus or AccuLynx, your workflows (permits, inspections, claims), and your internal rhythm.
  3. They “connect the dots” and begin to contribute.
  4. But then… they leave. Maybe because another company offered a couple bucks more, or maybe because admin work feels like grunt work.
  5. You restart the cycle: hire again, train again, rinse and repeat.

This isn’t just annoying, it’s expensive. According to research, replacing an employee costs, on average, 20–30% of their annual salary.
For an administrative hire making $40,000–$60,000, that could easily be $8,000–$18,000+ per turnover, not even counting the opportunity cost of your time.
Plus, while you’re in training mode, you’re not out selling or running jobs: you’re stuck onboarding. That slows growth.

Why “Good Admin” Is a Unicorn

What do roofing contractors really want when they hire admin? A mythical creature:

  • Someone who knows AccuLynx or JobNimbus deeply (not just the basics), you’re asking for 60–90 days or more of system training.
  • Someone who gets roofing workflows: permits, insurance, inspections, close-out. That’s not entry-level bookkeeping.
  • Someone who doesn’t need constant supervision, but most admins never reach full independence.
  • Someone who stays for the long haul, but turnover in administrative roles is common, especially if the work is repetitive or underpaid.

In reality, hiring “someone who checks every box” is rare; almost a unicorn. So when contractors try to find that person, what they usually get is someone with some skills but high churn.

What Actually Causes “More Work”

If you’re finding that hiring more people is actually creating more work, here’s why:

  1. Training time outweighs execution — For the first 4–6 months, you're pouring energy into onboarding, rather than scaling.
  2. You’re micromanaging — Because the new person doesn’t fully understand the job, you have to review everything: permit uploads, contract drafts, supplement tasks.
  3. Data mistakes compound — Wrong names, duplicated contacts, mis-filed documents = bad CRM data → bad decisions → missed jobs.
  4. Turnover resets everything — Every time someone leaves, you reset the clock on hiring and training.
  5. Personal cost — Many roofing owners confess: “I’m always training. I don’t get to be with my family. I’m on the phone. I just can’t step away.”

This is the “more work” trap: you didn’t just hire somebody. You added a recurring burden.

The Model That Actually Works (Yes, There Is a Better Way)

What if you could ditch the hiring treadmill and still get the admin work done: clean, consistent, and without burning yourself out?

Here’s what really works:

Roofing-Specific Operations Teams

Instead of hiring general admins, roofing companies that scale partner with operations teams that specialize in roofing. These teams are:

  • Already trained in JobNimbus, AccuLynx, and other roofing CRMs. No 3-month ramp-up.
  • Fluent in roofing workflows, including permits, supplements, insurance, production, scheduling, and closeout.
  • Structured to own outcomes, not just tasks: they don’t just “do admin,” they “run your office.”
  • Redundant and resilient: since it’s a team, sick days, vacations, or turnover don’t bring everything to a screeching halt.

This isn’t outsourcing a VA to type emails; it’s partnering with a real operations engine that gets roofing.

It’s Low Season. Time to Stop the Treadmill

If there's ever a time to make a change, it's now, during your slower season.

  • You have breathing room to evaluate your admin model.
  • You can onboard a team without the fire of rush jobs breathing down your neck.
  • You can set up well-defined roles, SLAs, and performance metrics for your new ops team.
  • You’ll start storm season with systems that scale, not fall apart.

When you make the shift now, the payoff is huge: better consistency, fewer headaches, smoother installs, and less risk that your admin is a liability.

Final Thoughts

The old model “hire one admin, train, replace, repeat”  doesn’t scale.
It hurts your bottom line, stalls your ability to grow, and drains your energy.

Roofers who succeed long-term don’t rely on unicorn admins. They rely on ops teams built for roofing. Back-office partners who already know your systems, already speak your language, and already own the job flow.

Would you rather keep climbing the treadmill or step off for good?

Book a discovery call with Saenz Global [link].
We’ll walk you through a client’s actual operations setup, and show you how to scale services instead of admin.

Are you ready to scale your roofing business?

Schedule your call below

We Help Roofing Contractors Scale From 7 Figures To 8 Figures And Beyond!
Expand your admin bandwidth with our expert back office support team.